


Afternoon Tea at the Peninsula Hotel

Out for Local Street Food in Fo Tan
———————
Disclaimer: Prepare for political incorrectness and generalizations.
In Cantonese class we watched a program about relationships and dating in Hong Kong. The episode we watched discussed “Gong Neuih”, referring to the stereotype about Hong Kong women as gold-diggers. I was told later that “Gong Neuih” is considered derogatory. I used the term in conversation with some locals without realizing this and they quickly corrected me.
Apparently men in Hong Kong are frustrated with that women expect them to pay for everything, to buy expensive brand-name gifts for their girlfriends, and when married allow their wives to take control over family spending. As a result, men feel an incredible pressure to be wealthy. Without a respectable career and a steady income, they lack romantic prospects. They must also be willing to do many menial things for their girlfriends, like carrying her purse for her or taking her shopping and then carrying all of the shopping bags.
The women interviewed say that men/society expects them to look good and looking good costs money. If men wish to accuse women in Hong Kong of being image-obsessed and materialistic, then they should acknowledge that the rest of the city is guilty of it too.
Many HK women go to great lengths to achieve and maintain a slender figure. I saw a commercial while riding MTR (Yes, you can watch news reports and commercials while riding subway in Hong Kong) that featured an average-sized woman walking a dog. Unhappy with her weight, she walks into a parlor, the screen beams and she emerges skinny and happy—her dog barking enthusiastically. There are special non-surgical procedures that many “gong neuih” undergo to slim down, including one in which a weird electric massager goes over the abdomen. I’ve noticed is that there isn’t a stress to work out or to develop muscle definition. If you want to lose weight, don’t go running, just eat less. Or call one of the numbers printed in ads all over the MTR stations and make an appointment to have someone do that electric massager thingy to flatten your stomach.
Hong Kong is very commercialized. Though you can certainly buy things cheaply at the market and shop for reasonably priced clothes, brand-name stores are ubiquitous, with internationally recognized names wherever people shop. And there are too many major shopping malls in Hong Kong to count.
Out of this growing frustration, many HK men have gone to mainland China to find wives. Since they feel that women from the mainland aren’t as demanding, are more willing to have children, and allow the husband to maintain some degree of financial authority in the family. Strange because I’ve also heard that many Japanese women come to Hong Kong and learn Cantonese because they believe that men in Hong Kong treat their wives more equitably compared to Japanese men.
Afterwards, I felt the program we watched in class didn’t do justice to the topic or offer a balanced perspective. I wanted a stronger explanation of the role of money in Chinese relationships…
That day after class, I went with some friends to take part in the English tradition of Afternoon Tea at the Peninsula Hotel, a ritzy and obscenely expensive hotel in downtown Tsim Sha Tsui,. According to William, who is a tea connoisseur, going to the Peninsula Hotel for tea is a very popular activity for the British in Hong Kong. I had been invited along by Michelle. I met up with her and her friends at the MTR station. Among them was Jill from Shanghai. I’ve never met a Chinese girl like Jill; Jill is funny, outgoing, talkative, opinionated, and completely unafraid.
Within seconds of meeting her she asked me if I could speak Mandarin. I responded with “I can understand a bit but I can’t speak much” and then she erupted in Mandarin chatter. She spoke so quickly. I think I only got half of what she said. But the parts I did get were fantastic. She told me that men in Shanghai have to carry their girlfriend’s bags for them. If a man in Shanghai doesn’t carry his girlfriend’s bag, buy her gifts and demonstrate complete devotion, it’s considered unacceptable. I thought this was the most entertaining conversation I had ever had in a language I didn’t really know.
Upon arriving at the hotel, we ordered the afternoon tea set. I asked for Chinese tea. Since I care more about liking the tea I drink than I do about sticking to British tradition.
A heated debate then began over Chinese vs. Western ideas of love and money. We were at the Peninsula Hotel from 6:30 to 10:00PM…that’s how long we talked about it. Poor Michelle, who was the most fluent in Mandarin of the group, had to translate for the rest of us.
So the same stereotype about Hong Kong women exists in Shanghai as well. That they expect their boyfriends/husbands to do and pay for everything. Some locals have told me that they don’t think it’s true for all women—that it’s only a small group of women who behave this way in relationships. Other locals have told me they prefer to date foreigners for this reason.
According to Jill, it’s very common for men in Shanghai to have multiple girlfriends. In Western culture, saying “I love you” is a big deal and it means you only love that one person. In Chinese culture, words mean nothing, and actions mean everything. (On a related note: My popo says the same thing. She thinks I say “please” “thank you” and “sorry” too often. She tells me that those things don’t need to be said out loud. That you say it with subsequent actions and by feeling it in your heart.) A man can say I love you to one woman and just as easily repeat it to another. So how is love/fidelity measured in Chinese culture? With money.
But not so simple. China’s history has a poor country and many families’ experiences with poverty have made money and financial stability a high priority for Chinese people. Thus when a man spends his money on a woman, it is an act of devotion. It also means he is less likely to have multiple girlfriends or wives who he would also spend money on. So for married couples, when the woman controls the finances, it is her strongest guarantee that her husband is being faithful.
When a man saves up money over time in order to buy his wife or girlfriend an expensive gift, it says “I love you” in a way that words can’t. But this only reinforces the stereotype of the gold-digging HK/Shanghai woman. And Chinese men experience a growing pressure to make enough money to make his girlfriend/wife feel valued. In the same way that many HK men leave HK to find wives in mainland China, many Shanghai men leave the city to find wives from the countryside.
We left the Peninsula Hotel that evening exhausted. I felt strange and American. The longer I’m here the more I understand Chinese culture, but also the more I realize how Western I am.
I feel as though my values are a privilege. Growing up in the U.S. has allowed me to believe in things like individualism, independence, freedom, pursuing one’s passion. Here, it’s about responsibility, survival, family. Values that I have too, but ones I don’t really glorify in the way I do others.
For example, most young people in Hong Kong don’t leave home for college. They live with their families until they’re married. Grown men and women stay and live with their parents and grandparents, either to take care of them or because it’s too inconvenient to move out. Meanwhile in the States, we get our first taste of “freedom” as teenagers. We drive at 16 (in California) and at 18 we leave home for dorm life and frat parties. Hong Kong college students don’t really party on-campus. They get together with friends and then come home. A lot of it has to do with how expensive it is to live in HK and the fact that the universities here don’t have the space to house all of its students, especially when most of them are just a train/bus/MTR ride away.